DENVER, CO – SEPTEMBER 23: Colorado Rockies catcher Hunter Goodman (15) singles in the sixth inning during a game between the Arizona Diamondbacks and the Colorado Rockies at Coors Field on September 23, 2026 in Denver, Colorado. (Photo by Dustin Bradford/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images) | Icon Sportswire via Getty Images Earlier this month, Major League Baseball announced their Silver Slugger finalists. That Colorado Rockies catcher Hunter Goodman was one of them came as no surprise, especially to Rockies fans who gloried in the 41 homers their two-time All-Star catcher hit over the course of the 2026 season.Remember this?View LinkGoodman won his first Silver Slugger in 2025, and should he do so again, he would be the first Rockie with back-to-back Silver Sluggers since Trevor Story did it in 2018 and 2019.Still, Arizona Diamondbacks catcher Gabriel Moreno had a solid season himself, including winning the National League Batting Title, so it’s worth comparing the criteria for the award and considering how the two NL West catchers compare.What are the criteria?MLB.com’s Manny Randhawa writes of the Silver Slugger,The Silver Slugger Award is presented to the best hitter at each position in each league annually, and it is voted on by MLB managers and coaches (who are not allowed to vote for players on their own teams). The coveted honor was established in 1980, with new categories for best-hitting utility player (2022) and best offensive team (2023) added in recent years.Two points here are worth noting:The award goes to the best hitter.Managers and coaches cannot vote for their own players.For me, the first line — “the best hitter” — stands out. That means the Silver Slugger should go to the player who has made the most offensive contributions to his team via hitting — and that doesn’t necessarily mean the most glamorous hits. Rather, it refers to consistent offensive production, so for me, that’s a key consideration.How do Moreno and Goodman stack up?How do the two catchers compare? Here’s the data according to StatHead:The first thing to note is that in terms of offensive opportunities, both Moreno and Goodman had very similar years. Moreno played in 130 games while Goodman was in 138. (Both spent some time on the Injured list.) As a result, Goodman had 25 more plate appearances. Still, the comparison between the two players operates under similar sample sizes. Now to the specifics. Moreno’s 6.7 rWAR is significantly higher than Goodman’s 2.6 rWAR, an indicator that Moreno was (significantly) the better overall player.Those numbers are born out in the rest of the data. Moreno had 20 more hits than Goodman did (147 to 127, respectively), and he had a substantially higher batting average (.311 to .245, respectively). Granted, baseball has developed better tools for measuring hitting, so consider the other numbers.Goodman outslugged Moreno by a lot — he had 41 home runs to Moreno’s 16 — and finished the season with
Content Source: Yahoo News
Image Credit: Getty Images
All rights to the news content and images belong to their respective copyright owners.