​Colin Cowherd, the Sports host for Fox Sports, urged a former San Antonio Spurs announcer to consider pursuing legal action after he was reportedly fired over an alleged affair. The sequence began earlier this week when Jacob Tobey, the Spurs’ lead play-by-play announcer, posted an unusual update on his Instagram Story. In the message, Tobey claimed: This is my girlfriend of six years. But I cheated on her with Loren Waters. @lorenkwatrs So feel free to continue following me if you really think I’m a good guy because I’m not. 🙂 The post also included a photo featuring Tobey with his girlfriend.
Tobey followed up with another Story, this one showing several photos from a photo booth. He captioned it: “Me and the new girl LorenkWaters.” Loren Waters is the sister of guard Lindy Waters III, who was a Spurs player in recent seasons. Waters III became a free agent, and his most recent stint with the Spurs was in the 2025-26 season.
On Thursday, Front Office Sports cited a source claiming Tobey had been fired due to the alleged affair. The same report noted that Tobey’s girlfriend later disclosed that she had been the one posting from his account, adding more complexity to the situation.
Responding to the development on The Herd, Cowherd expressed disbelief upon learning that Tobey had lost his job over alleged infidelity. He remarked that he was surprised to learn that someone could be fired in the United States for cheating on a girlfriend, not even a wife, describing the situation as unprecedented and notable. Cowherd commented that this was a “big story” and suggested that perhaps Tobey should consult an attorney, calling the scenario “crazy.” He added that the situation felt unsettled and puzzling, underscoring how surprising the firing appeared to him.
The broader context involves public figures in sports broadcasting, workplace conduct, and the repercussions that can follow personal actions. While details continue to unfold, the incident underscores the evolving discussions around ethics, accountability, and what constitutes grounds for employment decisions within sports media organizations. The original reporting from Mediaite highlighted Cowherd’s reaction to the news and framed the episode as a noteworthy example of employer responses to personal relationships and alleged infidelity in the digital era.
As this story developed, observers and fans weighed in on the balance between private conduct and professional responsibilities, and on how teams and networks navigate personnel decisions when personal actions become widely publicized. The situation also draws attention to how social media disclosures and influencer-era transparency can accelerate the spread of allegations, potentially impacting reputations and career trajectories before formal conclusions or investigations are complete. For those following sports media news, the Tobey controversy offers a case study in how off-field conduct can intersect with on-air roles, sponsorship considerations, and organizational branding, prompting questions about due process, fairness, and the appropriate thresholds for termination in similar scenarios.
In summary, the saga centers on Jacob Tobey’s reported firing amid allegations of an extramarital-like affair, claims that his girlfriend later acknowledged posting from his account, and Colin Cowherd’s baffled reaction on his show regarding whether personal indiscretions like cheating on a girlfriend should or could lead to job loss. The evolving coverage reflects broader debates about workplace ethics, social-media-driven revelations, and the consequences for broadcasters and sports personnel when their private lives intersect with public employment. The Mediaite report capturing Cowherd’s astonishment frames the piece as a talking point in contemporary sports media discourse.