​As ESPN continues to roll out Top 10 lists for every position, the Eagles are stacking up recognition as one of the league’s premier rosters. They’ve already landed one of the top running backs in Saquon Barkley and secured two of the top cornerbacks in Quinyon Mitchell and Cooper DeJean, with votes for Riq Woolen adding to the appeal. Now, Philadelphia adds two standout defensive tackles to the mix in Jalen Carter and Jordan Davis. Notably, none of the Eagles’ edge rushers cracked the Top 10 at their position, and while Dallas Goedert received some Top 10 votes among tight ends, he ultimately did not land a ranking.
Here’s a summary of what evaluators had to say about the Eagles’ dominant interior defenders. Carter’s ranking proved tricky for some voters, who pointed to inconsistent performances and a dip in production in 2025 as reasons for hesitancy, according to Fowler. “He’s a problem,” one veteran NFL defensive coach remarked. “A game-wrecker. You feel his presence out there consistently.” Yet other evaluators argued that his impact isn’t uniform on every snap. A few voters contended that Carter isn’t the best defensive lineman on his own team, with Jordan Davis earning that label in their eyes.
“He flashes 10 times a game but gets dragged far too often by average players,” one NFL coordinator said, highlighting the split in opinion. Another veteran defensive coach acknowledged that, while Carter might be the superior talent, Davis had a better season in 2025, making the case for several evaluators to place Davis ahead of Carter on their lists, as noted by Fowler. Davis has emerged as a star in his fourth season. The 2022 first-round pick, weighing 336 pounds, has posed a consistent challenge for guards and centers. Multiple voters favored Davis over Carter, seeing him as the more complete presence up front. “He’s just so exceptionally strong and consistent,” one coordinator remarked. “And he’s gotten better as he’s aged and in better shape.”
The list also features Jeffrey Simmons, Jalen Carter, and Jordan Davis, with former Eagles defensive tackle Milton Williams earning recognition as well. As fans and analysts consider where Carter and Davis should be placed among the top interior defenders in the league, the question remains: did the evaluators get it right with their rankings? Share your thoughts in the comments.
Would you rank Jalen Carter and Jordan Davis among the other top defensive tackles on this list? Do you agree with the evaluators’ placements? Let us know your view.