​Ederson should have been Manchester United’s first summer signing, with all deal formalities settled at the start of June. Only the medical assessments stood between him and confirmation of the move. Yet, at the final hurdle, the deal now faces the risk of collapse due to fresh concerns about his fitness.
The core issue centers on the meniscus injury he sustained during the 2025/26 season, between late August and late September. That setback kept him out for roughly a month and caused him to miss six fixtures. Meniscus problems worry clubs because they can signal longer-term knee issues, and given the Premier League’s relentless demands and high-intensity schedule, such injuries can flare up again.
While United are prepared to walk away from the deal and redirect their attention elsewhere, their hesitancy may have opened the door for a Premier League rival: Newcastle United. Sport Mediaset reports that Atalanta will look to renew Ederson’s contract, which expires in 2027, and Newcastle are ready to lodge an offer to bring him to the top flight. It would be a startling twist if Newcastle were to secure Ederson, ignoring the concerns that led United to pause the deal.
With Newcastle’s midfield exodus already underway—Sandro Tonali gone and Bruno Guimarães reportedly eyed for an Arsenal switch—Ederson could become a pivotal figure in their rebuild in central areas. Next season could feel unusually hostile for United, who may end up confronting several of their coveted midfield targets in rival colors. Players such as Elliot Anderson, Tonali, Mateus Fernandes, and Ederson could line up against United, each keen to prove a point. They might revel in reminding United what they missed, much like Aaron Wan-Bissaka does when facing his former club.
Nevertheless, there remains a belief that INEOS, ever cautious in their approach to recruitment, will strike deals that justify their prudence. Passing on certain transfers could ultimately prove prudent in the long run. Andrey Santos already looks like a superb addition to United’s engine room. If two more solid midfield signings follow, Michael Carrick will gain the reliable core needed to drive his resurgence project forward.
Featured image by Marco Luzzani/Getty Images
The Peoples Person has long been one of the world’s leading Manchester United news outlets. Follow us on Bluesky at @peoplesperson.bsky.social for better SEO.