The Cincinnati Reds have not delivered the kind of 2026 season many fans expected after last year’s encouraging step forward. Reaching the MLB playoffs in 2025, even though it ended quickly with a two-game Wild Card Series loss to the Los Angeles Dodgers, still felt like meaningful progress for a young team trying to build something sustainable. Instead of carrying that momentum into the following year, Cincinnati has struggled to stay in contention, putting the front office in a difficult position ahead of the MLB trade deadline.
The Reds now appear to be in a complicated middle ground. They may need to sell off certain pieces at the deadline, but that does not necessarily mean they have to tear everything down and enter a full rebuild. Cincinnati still has a strong young core, and several key players remain under cost-controlled contracts for years to come. That gives the franchise a legitimate foundation and allows the front office to think beyond short-term disappointment. The Reds are not starting over from scratch. They are trying to determine which players are part of the next winning window.
Elly De La Cruz remains the obvious face of the franchise and one of the most exciting young stars in Major League Baseball. However, another young player has forced his way into that same conversation this season: third baseman Sal Stewart. While the Reds have been inconsistent as a team, Stewart has been one of the organization’s biggest bright spots and one of the most productive rookies in baseball.
Stewart made his MLB debut late last season in September and immediately gave Cincinnati fans a glimpse of his potential. In 18 regular-season games, he looked comfortable at the plate and showed why the Reds viewed him as a major part of their future. He also stood out during the Wild Card round, where he was one of Cincinnati’s most productive hitters despite the team’s early postseason exit. That brief introduction has carried over in a major way during the 2026 season.
Before the All-Star break, Stewart appeared in 95 games and posted a .256 batting average, a .338 on-base percentage, an .812 OPS, 19 home runs and 65 RBIs. Those numbers were strong enough to earn him the first All-Star selection of his career and establish him as the clear frontrunner for National League Rookie of the Year. For a Reds team searching for long-term answers, Stewart has quickly become one of the most important players in the organization.
That raises an important question for Cincinnati: should the Reds sign Sal Stewart to a long-term contract extension before he gets close to free agency? Stewart is currently under team control through the 2031 season, so there is no immediate pressure to get a deal done. The Reds could wait several more years before seriously addressing his future. However, waiting could also become expensive if Stewart continues to develop into one of the better young hitters in the National League.
Small-market MLB teams have become more aggressive in recent years when it comes to extending young players early in their careers. These deals often give the player life-changing financial security while allowing the team to lock in prime years at a more manageable price. For a franchise like Cincinnati, that strategy makes a lot of sense. The Reds are not a team that can consistently win bidding wars in free agency, so identifying and extending homegrown talent is critical.
A recent example is JJ Wetherholt of the St. Louis Cardinals, who signed an eight-year, $112.5 million contract extension despite being a first-year player. That kind of deal shows how teams are willing to bet early on elite young talent before the price climbs even higher. Stewart is in a similar position. He has just over 100 total big-league games under his belt, but his production has already matched the expectations that followed him as a former first-round pick in the 2022 MLB Draft.
The talent has never been the issue with Stewart. The question is whether the Reds believe this version of him is real and sustainable. Based on what he has shown so far, Cincinnati should feel confident. His power production, approach at the plate and ability to handle pressure all point toward a player who can be a long-term centerpiece. If the Reds wait too long, his value could rise dramatically, especially if he wins National League Rookie of the Year or continues producing at an All-Star level.
Signing Stewart to a long-term extension now would be a smart move for both sides. The Reds would gain financial certainty and potentially save money over the life of the deal, while Stewart would receive security early in his career. For Cincinnati, locking up franchise-caliber players before they reach arbitration or free agency is not just a smart strategy. It is a necessary one.
The Reds may not be where they hoped to be in 2026, but Sal Stewart has given the franchise a major reason to be optimistic. If Cincinnati wants to build a consistent winner around young stars like Elly De La Cruz and Stewart, the front office should be proactive. Extending Sal Stewart now could be one of the most important moves the Reds make for their long-term future.
Content Source: Yahoo News
Image Credit: Getty Images
All rights to the news content and images belong to their respective copyright owners.