Deshaun Watson beating Shedeur Sanders as Browns’ Week 1 starter is just the beginning. Now, a tenuous reality awaits

By Jori Epstein — In News — August 25, 2026

   ​When Deshaun Watson booed the boos that rained down from fans on Saturday, the Cleveland Browns quarterback questioned not only his fan base’s actions but also their intentions.”I think the whole world knows it has nothing to do with the performance,” Watson told reporters after the 31-7 loss.The line left plenty to unpack about the history between quarterback and fan base. It also seemed to gain further relevance Monday when the Browns named Watson their starting quarterback for their season opener. Because while Watson (accurately or not) believed fans’ boos had “nothing to do with the performance,” Cleveland’s decision to name Watson its Week 1 starter has plenty to do with it. If the Browns’ decision was about fan popularity or podium performance or medium- to long-term upside, 2025 fifth-round pick Shedeur Sanders would have received the nod Monday.Play Yahoo’s new College Fantasy Football game: Create or join a league now!Instead, a conversation about who gives the club its best chance to beat the Jacksonville Jaguars in Jacksonville on Sept. 13 unfolded.Head coach Todd Monken chose Watson.”You don’t ignore the fans and the tax that maybe something like that can put on the organization, but we also have to make football decisions,” a person with knowledge of the Browns’ decision-making factors told Yahoo Sports. “You also can’t be emotionally hijacked and not make what you think is the sound, right football decision.”Multiple sources with knowledge of the Browns’ decision-making factors suggest: The decision to name Watson rather than Sanders did not arrive via a landslide. This was not a decision about who is “good” or “bad” and perhaps not a decision about who is the better or worse NFL quarterback.”I do think there’s maybe a little bit of an element here in terms of what you value in terms of their relative strengths and weaknesses,” a second person with knowledge of the Browns’ decision-making factors told Yahoo Sports. “Deshaun’s athletic. You’ll have the operation right. He’s really good pre-snap. Shedeur, he’s accurate. He’s very, very poised in the pocket. He’s a good drop-back passer and he can create enough off schedule with his legs, but you’re not going to do QB designed run.”Monken opted to promote the player with 72 career starts whom he believes is superior in nuances like the silent count required on the road, rather than the seven-start player whose quarterbacking skills may deserve the edge.Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson (4) is the starter for Week 1, but Shedeur Sanders (2) could still potentially start games later this season. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster)AP Photo/Carolyn KasterWatson’s strengths — which are different from those of Sanders, whether or not they are better — won out. For now.That tenuous reality was clear even as Monken sandwiched a “this is not a week-to-week decision” comment between his notes that Watson is going to start “against Jacksonville” and “ultimately, we’re about Week 1.”How much  

Content Source: Yahoo News

Image Credit: Getty Images

All rights to the news content and images belong to their respective copyright owners.