​Former Buffalo Bills wide receiver Brandin Cooks still appears to be wrestling with the memory of a controversial non-catch in the divisional round of last season’s NFL playoffs against the Denver Broncos. In a candid conversation with The Athletic’s Tim Graham, Cooks said he would keep processing the moment until he can return to the field, and that the most important takeaway for him is his unwavering belief that the ball should have been ruled a catch. “I will continue to process it until I get back on the field, but I think the biggest thing I can say is that I still feel like it was a catch,” he told Graham.
The play in question came at a critical juncture late in the fourth quarter. With the Bills facing a 3rd-and-11 at their own 36-yard line and the game tied at 30-30, Bills quarterback Josh Allen lofted a deep pass intended for Cooks. The ball initially appeared to be caught by Cooks, but Broncos cornerback Ja’Quan McMillian ripped the ball away from him just as the two went to the ground. The referees ruled it an interception, a decision that the NFL later upheld, prompting scrutiny and debate among fans and analysts about the play’s true possession and catch status.
Denver capitalized on the untimely turnover by driving the field and kicking a field goal, sealing a 33-30 victory over Buffalo. For Cooks, who is 32 years old, the post-season incident is not just a slice of game-day memory but a potential defining moment in his professional future. As an unsigned free agent, his career trajectory could be influenced by how teams interpret his ability to contribute and remain durable, even as the lingering memory of the non-catch lingers in public discourse.
Cooks’ reflection on this play comes amid ongoing conversations about how catches are officiated and reviewed in high-stakes games. The debate over whether the ball touched the ground, control, and simultaneous actions by defenders can sway outcomes in dramatic fashion, fueling discussions on whether the catch rule sufficiently protects offensive players while maintaining fairness in officiating. While the NFL has stood by its ruling on this particular play, the broader questions about catch definitions and the consistency of rulings continue to recur in the wake of such contentious calls.
As Cooks continues his career, the silence surrounding a possible return to the NFL does little to quiet the intrigue surrounding this moment. If he signs with a new team, the memory of that disputed play may fade into the background as he contributes on the field; if not, the turnover could be remembered as the final snap of his professional playing days. In the meantime, fans and analysts will likely revisit the play’s details, re-examine the angles, and debate whether the catch call should have stood, illustrating how a single play can resonate far beyond the immediate game and influence the legacy of a veteran receiver.
Social: Follow Broncos Wire on Facebook and Twitter/X. Did you know: These 25 celebrities are Broncos fans. This article originally appeared on Broncos Wire: Brandin Cooks still thinks Ja’Quan McMillian interception was a catch for better SEO.