​The Cincinnati Reds selected former Moeller High School standout Matt Ponatoski in the 18th round of the 2026 MLB Draft, 542nd overall. Reds chief of scouting Joe Katuska noted that Ponatoski was chosen for his potential as a pitcher. Ponatoski, who excelled in both football and baseball at Moeller, had previously committed to serving as the quarterback for the Kentucky Wildcats. As of June, Ponatoski stated that pursuing a career in MLB remained his top option, even amid college football possibilities. He now faces a decision deadline of July 27 to sign with Cincinnati or honor his commitment to the Wildcats.
During his senior year, Ponatoski helped lead Moeller to a deep postseason run, culminating in an appearance in the state title game, where the Crusaders were edged by St. Xavier. In the OHSAA Division I state baseball semifinals on June 11, 2026, Ponatoski pitched for Moeller against Perrysburg at Credit Union Park in Akron, Ohio, showcasing the skills that drew the Reds’ attention.
Ponatoski’s draft selection continues a narrative of multi-sport excellence and high-level pitching ability honed at Moeller High School. His journey has drawn interest from both professional baseball and collegiate football circles, underscoring the versatility and athletic pedigree that motivated Cincinnati to invest an 18th-round pick in his future. The decision looming for Ponatoski—whether to sign with the Reds or play for Kentucky—will shape the next chapter of a career that began long before the MLB Draft and remains rooted in the standout performance he demonstrated on Moeller’s fields. This development marks another notable milestone for Ponatoski, a former Crusader whose name has become closely linked with both the heritage of Moeller athletics and the evolving landscape of collegiate-to-professional sports opportunities.