Kurt Van DykeCredit: Kurt Van Dyke/FacebookNEED TO KNOWSurfer Kurt Van Dyke lived a seemingly idyllic life in Costa Rica until he was killed in a violent home invasion earlier this yearHis girlfriend and another man were arrested last week in connection with his slayingThe family of the beloved surfer says they are shocked by her arrest but were also suspicious about details surrounding the deadly attack, per CBS NewsThings weren’t adding up for Kurt Van Dyke’s family when they learned that the benevolent surfing legend had been tortured and then murdered in a violent home invasion that left his girlfriend largely unscathed.On Feb. 14, California native Van Dyke, 66, known as “King,” was found under a bed at a residence in Hone Creek, near Puerto Viejo de Talamanca, in Costa Rica, with multiple stab wounds and signs that he had been strangled, Costa Rica’s Judicial Investigation Agency (OIJ) announced.Van Dyke’s girlfriend, who has only been identified by her last name, Arroyo, was found zip-tied after the attack but didn’t suffer any serious injuries, police said at the time, CBS News reports.Now, nine months after Van Dyke’s brutal slaying, Arroyo and a 34-year-old man with the surname Gutiérrez, were arrested on suspicion of participating in his murder, the country’s Judicial Investigation Agency (OIJ) announced on Nov. 12, Teletica.com, theLos Angeles Times and SF Gate reported.The man and Van Dyke’s girlfriend had allegedly “planned a robbery targeting the American with the intent of obtaining the PINs for bank cards” linked to the Hotel Puerto Viejo in Puerto Viejo de Talamanca that he owned, officials said, CBS reports.Van Dyke’s brother, Peter Van Dyke, told CBS News that he and his family found it “shocking” that she was arrested.At the same time, however, he said they thought it was “extremely odd” that Arroyo had emerged from the violent attack largely unscathed, but said he “didn’t want to make any speculations.”Kurt Van DykeCredit: Kurt Van Dyke/Facebook“We had our suspicions,” he told CBS News.PEOPLE previously reported that Van Dyke was at a residence in Puerto Viejo with Arroyo when at least two armed men stormed inside, threatened them with a firearm and held them in a room for several minutes before stealing valuables.Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for PEOPLE’s free True Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases.Van Dyke was tortured and beaten when the suspects were unable to access his banking information, OIJ Deputy Director Vladimir Muñoz said, La Nación reported. The OIJ Deputy Director also said parts of the attack appeared to be “staged,” perLa Nación.Born in Santa Cruz, Calif., to a well-known surfing family, Van Dyke grew up “ripping pipelines.”He learned how to surf from an early age from his parents, Gene Van Dyke and Betty Van Dyke, who pioneered the sport in northern Cal