​Anthony Volpe, the New York Yankees shortstop, has long faced questions about his defense, despite winning a Gold Glove early in his career. Recently, concerns have grown that his fielding has regressed, undermining the prospect of him becoming the franchise cornerstone many hoped for. Some analysts suggest a positional shift could unlock his potential. Joel Sherman on The Michael Kay Show argued that Volpe has the arm for second base and often appears rushed at shortstop, implying he might be more effective at second base with a different team. Sherman asked whether Volpe could become a successful second baseman outside New York, noting that his current struggles might stem from trying to hurriedly compensate for his arm. While Sherman’s theory is provocative, it also highlights a broader question: if the Yankees consider trading Volpe, would another club value him enough to give meaningful returns, given his inconsistent MLB track record? Volpe has shown flashes of capability, but those moments haven’t consistently translated into sustained success, leaving his long-term value uncertain for both the Yankees and potential trade partners.